Equal Compensation Lawyers Columbus, Ohio

Home » Practice Areas » Equal Compensation

Offering equal pay for equal work should be the simplest rule for any employer to follow, and when that rule is broken, a Columbus equal compensation lawyer can help. The sex, age, race, religion, nationality, or disability status of the person doing a job should not determine his or her pay. Only performance and experience should dictate pay rates.

Far too many companies fail this simple test of fairness, however. Despite the presence of federal laws like the Equal Pay Act (EPA), Fair Labor Standards Act, Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the Age Discrimination in Employment Act, and the Americans with Disabilities Act, employers continue subjecting workers to pay discrimination. Victims of such unfair and illegal treatment should contact an equal compensation lawyer in Columbus to discuss their options for receiving back wages, economic damages, and, in some cases, punitive damages. Individuals and entire groups can file lawsuits, depending on the circumstances.

The Equal Pay Act and Title VII

The EPA and Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 both address unequal pay, but they work differently. Understanding that difference matters when you are deciding how to pursue your claim.

The EPA is a narrower law. It focuses almost entirely on sex-based wage differences. To win an EPA claim, you generally do not need to prove that your employer intended to discriminate. You only need to show that you were paid less than a person of the opposite sex for doing substantially equal work. The employer then has the burden of proving a legitimate reason for the pay gap, such as seniority, a merit system, or a factor other than sex.

Title VII is broader. It covers pay discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin. Unlike the EPA, Title VII requires you to show that the pay difference was caused by intentional discrimination. Title VII also requires you to file a charge with the EEOC and receive a Right to Sue letter before you can bring a federal lawsuit. The EPA does not have that requirement. You can file an EPA lawsuit directly in court without going through the EEOC first, though filing with the EEOC is still an option.

In many cases, workers file claims under both laws at the same time. An equal compensation lawyer in Columbus can review your situation and advise which law, or combination of laws, gives you the strongest path forward.

Fair Labor Standards Act

After the EPA, the next largest group of unequal pay cases involve violations of the FLSA. This law requires employers to comply with the prevailing state minimum wage, pay overtime to qualified workers, and correctly classify workers as employees or contractors. Applying FLSA’s rules for overtime eligibility and contractor status can get very complicated. Speaking with a Columbus equal compensation attorney will help answer essential questions.

Ohio Law and Pay Discrimination

Ohio workers are protected by state law in addition to federal law. The Ohio Civil Rights Act, found in Ohio Revised Code Chapter 4112, prohibits employers from discriminating in compensation on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, military status, national origin, disability, age, or ancestry. Ohio law applies to employers with four or more employees, which means it covers some smaller employers that federal law may not reach.

Ohio law also allows workers to file a charge with the Ohio Civil Rights Commission (OCRC) rather than, or in addition to, the EEOC. The OCRC investigates complaints and can pursue remedies on behalf of workers. Alternatively, workers may file a private lawsuit in Ohio state court. Time limits apply to both routes, so acting promptly is important.

One practical advantage of Ohio law is that it can be used alongside federal claims. A Columbus equal compensation attorney can help you determine whether filing under both Ohio and federal law strengthens your case or opens up additional remedies.

Discrimination in Compensation, Equity, and Severance

Pay discrimination does not always show up in a paycheck. Employers sometimes discriminate through the full package of compensation and benefits they offer. Workers who suspect they are being treated unfairly should look beyond base salary and consider all of the following areas.

Compensation

Discriminatory compensation includes more than just wages. Bonuses, commissions, overtime assignments, shift differentials, and paid leave can all be distributed in discriminatory ways. If your employer consistently gives higher-paying assignments, larger bonuses, or more overtime hours to workers of a different race, sex, or other protected class, that pattern may support a pay discrimination claim.

Equity and Ownership Interests

In some workplaces, compensation includes stock options, profit-sharing, or other equity-based benefits. If these ownership interests are offered or awarded in a way that excludes or disadvantages workers because of a protected characteristic, that treatment may violate the same laws that govern wage discrimination. Equity compensation is often less visible than a salary difference, which makes it easier for employers to disguise discriminatory patterns. Documenting what you have been offered, and what your peers have received, is an important first step.

Severance

Severance pay and separation agreements are another area where discrimination can occur. If workers who are laid off or terminated receive different severance packages based on protected characteristics rather than legitimate business reasons, that difference may be unlawful. Severance agreements also frequently include releases of legal claims. Before signing any severance agreement, you should speak with an equal compensation attorney in Columbus. Signing a release without understanding its terms could prevent you from pursuing a pay discrimination claim you would otherwise have the right to bring.

Restrictive Covenants and Your Right to Pursue a Claim

Many employment contracts include restrictive covenants such as non-compete agreements, non-solicitation clauses, and confidentiality provisions. These clauses can feel intimidating when you are considering whether to speak up about pay discrimination.

However, a restrictive covenant cannot legally prevent you from filing a pay discrimination charge with the EEOC or the Ohio Civil Rights Commission. Federal and Ohio law protect your right to file such charges regardless of what your employment contract says. What these covenants can do is limit your ability to work for a competitor, contact former clients, or disclose certain business information after you leave your job.

If your employer is using a confidentiality clause or non-disclosure agreement to silence you about pay practices, that use of the agreement may itself be unlawful in certain circumstances. A Columbus equal compensation lawyer can review your contract and advise you on what your agreement actually restricts and whether any of its terms are enforceable under Ohio law.

Holding Employers Accountable for Pay Discrimination

The EPA allows unfairly compensated employees to take their cases directly to court. Complaints brought pursuant to federal antidiscrimination law like Title VII require the EEOC to issue the Right to Sue before a plaintiff can file a lawsuit on FEDERAL claims. A dedicated Columbus equal compensation lawyer can assist an unfairly paid employee in navigating this process.

Another concern is that many pay discrimination cases go through mediation or arbitration before, or instead of, a civil trial. Hiring an attorney at a law firm with experience representing plaintiffs in alternative dispute resolution proceedings will help an unequally compensated employee achieve his or her best outcome. The Columbus overtime pay lawyers at The Friedmann Firm have handled both types of processes.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it legal in Ohio to ask my coworkers what their salaries are?

Yes, in most cases. Federal law protects most private-sector employees who discuss their wages with coworkers. The National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) gives most non-supervisory employees the right to discuss pay, hours, and working conditions with one another. An employer cannot legally fire you, discipline you, or threaten you for asking a coworker what he or she earns, or for sharing your own pay information.

There are some exceptions. Supervisors and managers are generally not covered by the NLRA. Some employees who have access to confidential payroll information as part of their job duties may have more limited rights to share that information. A confidentiality agreement that specifically covers salary information may also affect your situation, though such agreements can sometimes conflict with NLRA protections.

Ohio does not have a separate state law that independently grants or expands these rights for private-sector workers, so the federal NLRA framework generally controls. If you work for the state or a local government in Ohio, different rules may apply. If you are unsure whether your employer’s pay secrecy policy is legal, speaking with an equal compensation lawyer in Columbus can help you understand your rights before you take any action.

How can an equal compensation lawyer in Columbus, Ohio help me if I am being paid less than my coworkers for the same job?

An equal compensation lawyer in Columbus can help you in several practical ways. First, an attorney can evaluate the facts of your situation and tell you honestly whether what you are experiencing appears to violate the law. Not every pay difference is illegal. A lawyer can help you distinguish between a pay gap that may be unlawful and one that has a legitimate legal explanation.

If your situation does appear to involve illegal pay discrimination, an attorney can help you gather and organize the evidence you will need. This includes payroll records, job descriptions, performance reviews, and any communications that reflect how pay decisions were made. An attorney can also help you identify the right law or laws to pursue your claim under, whether that is the EPA, Title VII, the Ohio Civil Rights Act, the FLSA, or some combination.

An equal compensation lawyer can also handle the procedural steps on your behalf. This includes filing a charge with the EEOC or the Ohio Civil Rights Commission if required, responding to employer defenses, and representing you in negotiations, mediation, arbitration, or court. Having an attorney handle these steps protects you from making procedural mistakes that could harm your case. Time limits for filing pay discrimination claims are strict, and missing a deadline can eliminate your right to pursue a claim entirely.

What are the legal steps to take when filing a pay equity or compensation discrimination claim in Columbus, Ohio?

The steps depend on which law or laws apply to your claim, but the general process follows a similar path for most workers in Columbus.

Step 1: Document the pay disparity. Before doing anything else, gather as much information as you can about the pay difference. This includes your own pay history, any information you have about what coworkers in similar roles earn, your job description, and any performance reviews or evaluations. Keep records of any conversations or communications that are relevant to how pay decisions were made.

Step 2: Consult with an equal compensation attorney. An attorney can review your documentation, assess the strength of your claim, and advise you on which laws apply and what steps to take next. Our law office, the Friedmann Firm, offers free and confidential consultations for workers in Columbus and throughout Ohio.

Step 3: File a charge with the EEOC or the Ohio Civil Rights Commission, if required. If you are pursuing a Title VII or Ohio Civil Rights Act claim, you must file an administrative charge before you can sue in court. For Title VII, you generally must file with the EEOC within 300 days of the discriminatory act in Ohio, because Ohio is a “deferral state” with its own civil rights agency. The EEOC will investigate and may attempt to resolve the matter through mediation. If the EEOC does not resolve the charge, it will issue a Right to Sue letter. EPA claims do not require this step, but filing with the EEOC is still an option.

Step 4: Review any arbitration agreement. If your employment contract includes an arbitration clause, your attorney will need to determine whether your claim must go through arbitration rather than court, and what rules apply to that process.

Step 5: File a lawsuit or proceed to arbitration. Once administrative requirements are satisfied and the right forum is determined, your attorney will file your lawsuit in federal or state court, or initiate the arbitration process. From that point forward, your case will proceed through discovery, potential settlement negotiations, and, if necessary, a hearing or trial.

Acting quickly is essential at every stage. Missing a filing deadline can end your case before it begins. If you believe you are being paid less than your coworkers because of your sex, race, age, or another protected characteristic, contact a Columbus equal compensation lawyer as soon as possible.

Best Equal Compensation Attorney in Columbus, Ohio

Contact a Columbus equal compensation attorney today. Our law firm, The Friedmann Firm, offers free and confidential consultations. To schedule yours, please call or fill out our email form.

Employment Law

What Our Clients Say About Our Firm.

Office of The Friedmann Firm LLC