How Can an Employer Use Job Listings to Discriminate?
A settlement announced by the U.S. Department of Justice on Dec. 8, 2020, provides a clear, real-world answer to the question of how an employer can use job listings to illegally discriminate against people who are looking for work. These cases usually require a lot of investigation and testimony to reveal exactly how and why the employer was discriminating.
The investigation in this particular case involved a Texas-based IT staffing firm called IKON Systems, LLC. No employer can discriminate against job seekers based on national origin or race, as illustrated by this case.
Making It Clear That Only Certain Applicants Would Receive Interviews Is Illegal
According to a DOJ press release, authorities opened their investigation into Ikon’s recruiting practices in 2019. A U.S. citizen alerted DOJ’s Civil Rights Division that the company was posting job announcements containing lines such as “Looking for OPT, CPT, H4 EAD, and H-1B transfer.”
The codes are temporary work visa designations. Eight such statements were found in job listings Ikon posted from May 8, 2019, to September 21, 2019. Federal authorities determined the statements to be “facially discriminatory,” which means a typical person would read them and understand that only individuals who held the designated visas would receive serious consideration for employment.
Faced with a lawsuit under the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA), Ikon settled all claims by paying the job applicant who filed the complaint $15,000 and paying $27,000 in civil fines to the U.S. government. Ikon officials also agreed to “revise … policies and procedures, and train relevant employees and agents on the INA’s antidiscrimination provision.”
The INA provision referred to in the DOJ press release closely mirrors language in Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 that prohibits discrimination in employment based on race and national origin. Just as Title VII bans job listings that state things such as “Whites only” or “No Arabs,” job listings cannot specify a preference for visa holders to the exclusion of U.S. citizens.
Companies Can See Discrimination as a Bottom-Line Issue
The DOJ partnered with the U.S. State Department to enforce the INA provision banning employment discrimination. In October 2017, the agencies launched a Protecting U.S. Workers Initiative to “share information about employers that may be engaging in unlawful discrimination, committing fraud, or making other misrepresentations in their use of employment-based visas, such as H-1B, H-2A, and H-2B visas.”
A leading concern has been that U.S. based employers, especially those involved in computer programming and web development, may prefer to hire immigrants who have permission to work in the United States for a few years because such employees demand lower salaries and few benefits. The INA and other federal laws such as the Equal Pay Act, however, prohibit paying workers who do essentially the same job for the same company considerably different wages.
As Ohio attorneys who handle equal compensation cases, we have seen all kinds of unfair treatment of employees. Excluding entire groups of people from even applying for positions strikes us as particularly unjust and discriminatory.
We welcome opportunities to advise and represent Ohioans who have suffered other types of workplace discrimination based on their race, national origin, sex, age, religion, pregnancy, disability, or veteran status.
We offer free and confidential consultations, and we take appointments online. If you would prefer to speak with a lawyer directly, call us at 614.610.9755.
Rachel was absolutely amazing. As an attorney she really took the time to really listen to my concerns. She was honest and kept me informed every step of the way. The outcome was favorable on my behalf and I appreciate her efforts to achieve a good outcome. I would highly recommend her and the Friedmann firm to represent me if ever needed in future.
Working with Rachel Sabo from Friedmann Firm was absolutely amazing! She upholds integrity, honesty and without a doubt fights for what is right! Rachel was extremely transparent and real! Please don’t let wrong be right, Rachel will strive to advocate and put her whole heart in obtaining resolve in your situation! What an absolute blessing, she won my case in less than 1 week💪
My experience with the Friedmann Firm is an absolute 5 stars. From my very first call with Karen, to all of my communication with Rachel, everything exceeded all of my expectations. Rachel and Karen were so caring and understanding in a very sensitive situation. They responded immediately to any questions or concerns I had. I would HIGHLY recommend the Friedmann Firm. They are caring, professional, understanding, and I would trust them with any issue I have in the future.
Rachel and the Friedmann Firm were fantastic to work with. The thought of needing an employment lawyer was scary for me, it was confusing and complex. But Rachel listened, asked questions and took time to really understand me and my priorities. I felt calm, supported and excited for the first time in weeks after talking to her!! We worked together to review everything, set expectations and meet my priorities! Thanks Rachel and team for all your work!!!
Rachel Friedmann of the Friedman Firm was my attorney for a very recent legal matter. I would highly recommend Rachel based on her legal knowledge, her honest appraisal of the matter and expected outcomes, her open communication and timely responses to my questions and the matter itself, and her steadfastness in dealing with the opposing counsel until a final agreement was reached.
Rachel and her staff went over and above the call of duty to help me achieve fiscal resolution to my legal issue. She wasn’t always available to talk but was always responsive via text and email when in court out of the office and even on vacation. I feel she earned her percentage cut.
Couldn’t be happier with the representation I received from Jamie Bailey on my civil litigation case. She worked tirelessly to resolve the case and in the end negotiated a fair settlement on my behalf. I would highly recommend her to anyone! Thanks for everything Friedman law firm.
Friedman Firm was a great help in a difficult time in my life. They went above and beyond to get me back on track. Rachel was so good to work with and is extremely knowledgeable about the law and employment rights. Can't thank them enough for all there hard work. Highly recommend them to anyone.
The Friedmann Firm (specifically Pete Friedmann) represented me through what seemed like a never ending employment discrimination suit. The suit was filed just before Covid shut everything down in 2020. Add to that a former employer who refused to admit fault. In spite of all of that, Pete stood resolute in his representation of me and working for the best outcome for me. We ended up settling prior to trial and I was more than satisfied with the results. Pete was always available to answer questions and reassure me throughout this process. I highly recommend The Friedmann Firm!
Pete Friedmann and his firm are fantastic. He represented me for more than a year going through a suit with a previous employer. He walked me through every step of the process and was always quick to respond to any questions I had. My settlement came in and we parted ways with both sides being pleased with the outcome. I highly recommend the Friedmann firm and wouldn’t hesitate to use them again in the future if the need arose. Thank you, Pete!
Rachel and the Friedmann Firm have been amazing to work with. Rachel was very helpful, listened to our concerns and took our case. She communicated well throughout and really worked for us. We were very well represented!
I loved working with The Friedmann Firm. Rachel and Jamie are exceptional lawyers and were diligent in reviewing my case and letting me know of my options. Jamie was extremely thorough and handled even the smallest details of my case with ease. The entire process was seamless and they were always quick to respond to emails and calls. I would definitely recommend working with The Friedmann Firm.
I would recommend Rachel Sabo Friedmann and the Friedmann firm for severance negotiations. Rachel was always available and responsive and made an effort to ensure I was updated on every step of the process. Her diligent efforts produced a prompt resolution and we are very happy with the results!