Pay & Bonus Disputes
Home » Columbus » Pay & Bonus Disputes

Pay & Bonus Disputes Attorneys in Ohio

When you accepted an executive role with your employer, you agreed to compensation that may come in various forms, including base salary, equity compensation, or performance-based bonuses. But if the company fails to provide the compensation promised to you, you may find yourself in a legal dispute with your employer.

Disputes can arise due to complex contractual and legal issues, and you may need experienced legal counsel to evaluate your rights, advise you on your options, and advocate for your interests as you pursue the financial compensation you’ve earned through your hard work for your employer. Contact The Friedmann Firm, LLC, at our Columbus office for an initial case evaluation with our executive employment lawyers to learn how our firm can help you secure the compensation you deserve.

Understanding Pay and Bonus Disputes

An executive at a Columbus-area company may have a pay or bonus dispute against their employer if the company fails to pay contractually promised wages, withholds bonuses earned under agreed-upon metrics, denies promised benefits, devalues equity compensation, or makes unilateral changes to compensation plans. Disputes can arise due to circumstances such as:

  • Ambiguous contract language
  • Misinterpretation or misunderstanding of employment or compensation agreements
  • Broad agreement terms that give employers unlimited discretion over compensation payments
  • Employer retaliation or misconduct, including refusing to pay promised compensation due to financial constraints

Even executives and high-level employees operating under employment or compensation agreements that include contingent or performance-based compensation arrangements have legal protection under contract and employment law. Any employee who does not receive the compensation they believe is owed to them under their contract and applicable employment law may have a legal claim against their employer. 

Common Types of Pay and Bonus Disputes

At The Friedmann Firm, LLC, our Columbus lawyers have extensive experience in executive employment compensation disputes involving:                   

  • Unpaid or Underpaid Salary – Executives may have legal claims when companies fail to pay the base salary promised to the employee upon hire. Pay disputes may also arise when employers make deductions from paychecks not authorized by the employee or required by law.
  • Unpaid or Revoked Bonuses – Legal disputes can arise when companies fail to pay or revoke bonuses. However, disputes can become complicated depending on the discretionary or performance-based nature of the bonus. Executives may have claims when companies attempt to cancel or claw back bonus payments.
  • Misclassification – Employees may have pay-based claims when employers improperly classify them as exempt from overtime.
  • Performance-Based Compensation – Disagreements over performance-based compensation, including bonuses, equity compensation, and profit sharing, frequently arise over whether an executive or the company has reached the performance metrics required to entitle the executive to contingent compensation. Parties may also have disputes over the calculation of the compensation owed under the contractual formula.
  • Retaliation or Pay Reductions After Complaints – Executives may have legal claims when companies decline contingent compensation or reduce bonus salary and other compensation allegedly due to retaliation by an employer, including for whistleblowing or participating in other legal claims against the company.

Legal Protections for Employees in Ohio

Ohio law requires the regular payment of wages or salary earned by employees. Executives who do not receive a regularly scheduled paycheck can pursue legal action to compel payment from their employer. State contract law also protects employees’ right to receive compensation promised to them in employment or compensation agreements with their employers.

Disputes can arise when employers try to insert language in contractual agreements that waives compensation already earned by an employee. However, the law does not enforce agreements to waive earned compensation.

Employees who raise pay and bonus disputes may also receive whistleblower protection. When an employee reports pay practices that they believe violate the law and subsequently experience adverse employment actions, such as demotions, reductions in pay, disciplinary action, or termination, they may have legal action against their employer.

Proving a Pay or Bonus Violation

Executives who believe they have not received the compensation owed to them under contract or by state and federal employment laws may pursue legal action to recover that compensation. However, proving a pay or bonus dispute may require various evidence, such as:

  • Offer letters
  • Written employment or compensation agreements
  • Emails and other written correspondence regarding compensation or performance targets for bonuses or other contingent compensation

Legal counsel can also help prove your employer’s violation of your compensation rights by analyzing your pay and identifying inconsistencies in records or breaches of contracts you signed.

Employers may rely on contractual ambiguities or legal technicalities to argue they did not violate an employee’s right to compensation. Working with a knowledgeable attorney from The Friedmann Firm, LLC, can help you develop a case to prove that your employer owes you compensation under a contract or state and federal employment law.

How a Columbus Executive Employment Lawyer Can Help

Recovering the compensation you have earned can become stressful, especially when going up against a large employer. Hiring legal counsel can help level the playing field. An executive employment lawyer from The Friedmann Firm, LLC, can help you recover the compensation you deserve for your work by:

  • Reviewing your employment agreements and your company’s policies to identify your contractual rights and the company’s payment obligations
  • Pursuing initial settlement negotiations to secure the compensation you deserve and preserve employment relationships, if possible
  • Seeking contractual remedies, including pursuing alternative dispute resolution through mediation or arbitration
  • Filing complaints with state regulators or the U.S. Department of Labor, if necessary
  • Going to court when needed to demand your contractual or legal rights to compensation owed for your work or the performance metrics you’ve achieved

Hiring legal counsel as soon as possible when issues over compensation arise can help avoid escalation, retaliation in your current employment, and additional financial losses. 

Frequently Asked Questions

At The Friedmann Firm, LLC, we often get questions from our executive employee clients from across Ohio about how they can resolve a disagreement over their salaries or bonuses. Below, our Columbus employment dispute lawyers answer some of our most frequently asked questions.

Can an employer refuse to pay a promised bonus?

Whether an employer has the right to refuse to pay a bonus depends on various circumstances, including whether a high-level employee’s agreement with the employer creates a contractual right to a bonus and whether the employee met the contract’s conditions to entitle them to it. For example, an employer is likely under no obligation to pay a bonus conditioned on the company meeting specific financial targets if the company misses those targets. Employment agreements may also make bonuses discretionary, meaning an employer has a largely unfettered right to decide whether to pay them. 

However, if your employer has declined to pay you a bonus you believe you have a contractual right to, you should speak with a Columbus employment attorney as soon as possible. Your lawyer can review the contract’s terms to determine if you are correct and then advise you on the next steps you can take to get the pay you’re owed.

Can an employer change my compensation structure after I start working?

Employment agreements can give an employer the right to change agreed-upon bonus or commission structures. However, any changes should apply prospectively to future compensation and should not affect any compensation that an executive has already earned, such as performance-based bonuses whose criteria the employee has already met. If your employer tries to apply changes to compensation you’ve already earned, an executive pay disputes lawyer in Columbus can help you pursue a legal claim against them.

Does the law consider a bonus as part of wages/salary?

Whether a bonus qualifies as wages or salary depends on its legal characterization. The law considers non-discretionary bonuses (that is, bonuses earned based on defined performance goals or metrics) as wages or salary. Conversely, discretionary bonuses (those that an employer retains sole discretion over whether to pay, such as a holiday bonus) do not count as wages or salary. Thus, an employer can use non-discretionary bonuses to meet part of the weekly and annual salary requirements for the executive employee exemption and the annual salary requirement for the highly compensated employee exemption.

Can I claim a bonus after I’ve left the company?

Your right to receive a bonus after your employment ends depends on the terms of your employment agreement. Some executive compensation contracts require the executive to remain employed with the company on the bonus payment date. Other agreements entitle an executive to a performance bonus upon meeting the required metrics, even if they leave the company before the payment date. Agreements may contain provisions under which an executive might forfeit a bonus if their employment ends due to a termination for cause or misconduct.

If your employer terminated you for cause or misconduct, you should contact our employment law firm in Columbus to discuss your contractual right to receive any bonuses for which you have met the requirements. 

Are bonuses always discretionary?

Employers can offer discretionary or non-discretionary bonuses to employees. A discretionary bonus allows an employer to decide whether to pay it up to the payment date. A non-discretionary bonus, on the other hand, is usually spelled out in the employee’s contract and is subject to the employee meeting specific criteria to earn the bonus. Those bonuses are non-discretionary in that the employee has a contractual right to receive them once they meet the criteria set out in their contract or the company’s compensation policy. 

When resolving bonus disputes, attorneys may look beyond a contractual description of a bonus as “discretionary” to determine if the employer conditioned payment of the bonus on the employee or company meeting specific performance metrics or other objective criteria.

Why Choose Our Firm?

When a pay or bonus dispute puts your compensation for your hard work in jeopardy, you need experienced legal counsel to help seek the financial compensation you deserve. Choose an executive employment law attorney from The Friedmann Firm, LLC, to advocate for your right to compensation under your employment contract or employment law because:

  • Our attorneys have represented executives in compensation disputes since 2012. We have handled a wide range of pay and bonus disputes, including breach of contract claims for base salary, bonus eligibility disputes, and performance-based or contingent compensation calculations.
  • We understand the anxiety and stress you feel when a legal dispute involves your hard-earned compensation. Our attorneys will take the time to understand your needs, concerns, and goals to pursue a case strategy that achieves your objectives. Our firm won’t hesitate to stand up to employers who try to take advantage of your time and effort.
  • Our team boasts a proven track record, having handled over a thousand cases. We also offer flexible payment arrangements and representation agreements to make sure you have the legal counsel and advocacy you need to protect your financial interests.

Contact Our Ohio Employment Law Attorneys

Resolving a pay or bonus dispute with an employer requires dedicated, experienced legal counsel to advocate for your interests. Contact The Friedmann Firm, LLC, today for a confidential consultation with an executive employment compensation attorney to discuss your options. We’re ready to help you seek a favorable resolution to a compensation or bonus dispute that secures the pay you deserve for your hard work. We are located in Columbus and represent clients across Ohio.

Employment Law

What Our Clients Say About Our Firm.

Office of The Friedmann Firm LLC